Decisions, decisions, decisions. Your book cover’s the cornerstone of your character's adventure. And as a new novelist, it’s also a part of your origin story! However, when conjuring up a book cover that’s a feast for your perfect audience’s senses, do you turn to a book designer or illustrator?
Well, Scooby Doo, we’ve got a mystery on our hands. There’s a new writer in town (you!) whose book is about to be published. Plot twist: You’re struggling to find the right person to make your book stand out on the shelf. Who do they choose? A book designer whose expertise can conjure up a winning cover? Or a book illustrator whose masterful skills can highlight their novel’s charms? Or – simply – both?
Let’s take a deep dive into the differences and similarities between a book designer and a book illustrator. And while we’re at it, debunk some myths we’re cursed with, so you know exactly which choice is right for you.
Myth: Book Designers and Illustrators are the same
The first mythical creature to duel. Thankfully, you’ve got Miss Nat Mack – AKA mythbuster and part-time dragon slayer – on your hands! A common thought among novelists is that book designers and book illustrators are the same. But think of us as Loki. While we may share a common thread, we have many different variants. Let me show you why.
What is Book Design?
Book designers create, lay out and perfect the ins and outs of your novel’s appearance.
From front cover to final page, your book designer makes sure your story shines. The colour palette, the composition, the font. You name it, we cover it. Literally.
We uncover the perfect typography to capture the essence of your words. Craft the perfect photo placement to excite readers from the get-go. We’ll even whip up an illustrious spine that’ll spellbind shelves and worlds for years to come. All it takes is a wish… or more accurately, our stunning skills and your beautiful brief.
What does a book designer do?
You’re going to the book ball! Well, think of a book designer as your fairy godmother *wink, wink*. They wave their magic wand and conjure up a design that transforms your novel into a sales dream.
Is your edge-of-your-seat mystery in need of an adrenaline jolt? A book designer will use their know-how to find the right placement for any images, colour, and text on your book cover. This sparkling visual identity will sell your thriller in no time. Mystery solved! Well, almost…
What is book illustration?
Let me take you for a little journey behind the spine. Using the themes in your text, book illustration is an art form that transforms your words into an image. A powerful marketing tool, the right graphics can make or break your cover's ability to attract the target audience.
So, you’ve got a magical world full of heroes and villains? Well, a book illustrator is the perfect person to bring your novel to life. Drawing up colourful imagery or chilling scenery from scratch, your book illustrator transforms your characters, your setting, and your tone into a sight for the ages.
What does a book illustrator do?
Book illustrators use their wild imaginations to craft the perfect piece of >>artwork<< to adorn the cover of your book. It’s like nailing that perfect cosplay after months of planning. There’s no better feeling!
Careful looking under the cover, there’s a scary monster that’ll terrify you! A book illustrator will sketch an image from scratch based on the creatures or worlds inside, so your audience knows exactly what frights will befall them. Eeek! Besides, horror fans love when their spooky book looks like a horror novel. Wouldn’t you?
Myth: Book Designers can’t be book illustrators
*Buzz* Sorry, that’s the wrong answer. Would you like another go? Book designers can absolutely flex their illustration superpowers to make your cover feel fresh and exciting. I can attest to that. There’s more than enough room for artists to stretch their sketching skills while concocting a magical cover.
Do you want the best of both worlds? Why not find a unicorn designer who can combine exciting illustrations with a fully fleshed out exterior and typography?
Tip from the mind tap: Each illustrator has their own style. For example, my book illustrations use line-work to create different textures. On the other hand, there are also realistic illustrators. And character illustrators for genres like Middle Grade. Plus, digital illustrators who specialise in fantasy characters. Browse illustrators’ work to see what style you are most drawn to while keeping your target market in mind.
You’ll be casting a spell that’ll leave a lasting impression on readers.
Book Design vs Illustration examples
Looking for some examples? You’ve come to the right place! Let me call upon the cover coven to illuminate the differences.
BOOK DESIGN EXAMPLES
Mixing powerful visuals with a specific colour palette and striking font, I’ve crafted these cover designs to accentuate the tone and genre of each tale. Is your novel a dark and twisted mystery? Or a high-octane thriller? Then book design is the ideal way to conjure up a feeling of suspense from the very first page.
BOOK ILLUSTRATION EXAMPLES
Who doesn’t love a bit of spicy imagery on their cover? Taking a powerful image described in the novel, I’ve created an image that immediately stands out. Perfect for a scary horror or a suspenseful fantasy novel, bringing your imagination to life through illustration is an enchanting way to sell your tale.
Book illustrator or book designer – who do you choose?
That’s like choosing which Spider-Man actor is better. Extremely difficult (although I am a Tom Holland girl, myself). In the end, it’s all about finding the right person to summon a drool-worthy cover. And we’ve only just scratched the surface on typography! If you’re still unsure which is right for you, perhaps hiring a book designer-and-illustrator unicorn (like me) who’ll weave a spell of sparkling designs and a touch of vivacious imagery to perfectly tell your story is the best choice. Take a look at the cover coven or discover more book cover intel via the Miss Nat Mack blog.